The Brand Decisions No One Wrote Down
Last month we wrote about brand rules that come without their reasons. This month is about where those reasons usually end up: with people.
Every brand is the result of hundreds of decisions. Why the logo was redrawn. Why one color was retired. Why the tagline was shortened, and what the longer version used to say. Each decision made sense to the people in the room. Very few of them were written down.
Where Brand Knowledge Actually Lives
In most companies, it lives with a handful of people: a long-time designer, a marketing lead, a founder, or an agency that has held the account for years. When something new comes up, someone asks them. As long as they are around, the brand holds together.
What Happens When They Leave
People change roles, retire and move on. Agencies get replaced. When that happens, the guidelines stay but the judgment goes with them. The next team finds a rule with no history, and either follows it without question or quietly drops it. Neither choice is careless. They simply don’t know what the rule was protecting.
New tools widen the gap. A new vendor or an AI tool works only from what it is given. It has no one down the hall to ask.
What a Decision Record Looks Like
A decision record doesn’t need to be long. Here is one of our own.
- Decision
- Our favicon uses the two wide strokes of the A, not the star.
- Why
- At that size, the star on its own looked generic. Many brands use a similar shape. The strokes belong only to us.
- Who and when
- Our founder, October 2026.
- Revisit if
- A simpler single-stroke version proves to be ours alone.
Four lines. Anyone who meets that icon later knows what it protects, who to credit for it and when it would be fine to change it.
Start With Five
You don’t need to record everything at once. Pick the five brand decisions people ask about most often, and find the person who knows the answer. Write down what was decided, why, who decided and when it should be revisited. That alone will answer more questions than another page of rules.
The longer a brand runs, the more of it lives in memory instead of on paper. The best time to write it down is while the people who remember are still in the room.